Best Electric Fireplace Inserts: 3 Models Compared

Best electric fireplace insert for existing fireplace of 2026 — honest 3-product comparison with prices and verdicts.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. – Maya Bennett






LIVE DEAL– Western 33 selected US offer checked November 5, 2026$389.89
VS REVIEWUpdated November 5, 2026 – Maya Bennett – existing-fireplace formats and fit
VS
★ BEST OVERALL

PuraFlame Western 33-Inch Electric Fireplace Insert product image

PuraFlame
Western 33-Inch Electric

★★★★★ 4.7

$389.89

Check Price on Amazon

BEST BUDGET

LegendFlame Carl 30-Inch Electric Fireplace Insert product image

LegendFlame
Carl 30-Inch Electric Fireplace

★★★★★ 4.6

$326.69

Check Price on Amazon

BEST FOR OPEN HEARTHS

Dimplex Revillusion RLG25 Electric Log Set product image

Dimplex
Revillusion RLG25 Electric Log Set

★★★★☆ 4.4

$499.00

Check Price on Amazon

⚡ SHORT ANSWER

Start with Western 33 for a matching enclosed cabinet. Carl 30 lowers the outlay; RLG25 preserves an open masonry view without a room thermostat.

How we compared these three electric fireplaces

We compared dated US offers, exact dimensions, controls and installation documents. No physical testing was performed. Amazon averages remain separate from the four documentary criterion grades; higher price does not prove lower energy use.the trend report

Plan direct wall-outlet use and follow the appliance instructions.CPSC winter heater guidance

Offers and ratings at a glance

Feature PuraFlame Western 33-Inch Electric LegendFlame Carl 30-Inch Electric Fireplace Dimplex Revillusion RLG25 Electric Log Set
Best for Best Overall Best Budget Best for Open Hearths
Price checked $389.89 $326.69 $499.00
Amazon rating 4.7 / 5 4.6 / 5 4.4 / 5
Visible reviews 4612 650 832
Brand PuraFlame LegendFlame Dimplex

⇆ swipe horizontally on mobile – prices last verified November 5, 2026

Hands measuring the inner depth of an empty brick fireplace with a folding rule
Original measurement illustration. Check the complete opening against the chosen model’s manual before ordering.

The 3 picks, in detail

PuraFlame Western 33-Inch Electric Fireplace Insert product image

Best Overall

#1 – PuraFlame Western 33-Inch Electric

4.7 / 5 – 4612 reviews
$389.89
Price last verified 2026-11-05 on Amazon US
+ PROS

+ Finished three-sided brick-look firebox.
+8.78-inch outer depth, subject to the exact opening rules.
+ 750/1,500W settings and a rotary thermostat.
+ Flames without heat; remote crackling-sound controls.
+Exact EF45D manual with opening and ventilation guidance.
– CONS

x35.04-inch outer width exceeds the nominal 33-inch name.
x Plug-in only; this model cannot be hardwired.
xThree flame modes; thermostat dial lacks a precise temperature display.
KEY SPECS

Outer dimensions:35.04 x 26.99 x 8.78 in (width x height x depth)
Firebox dimensions:Listed firebox: 32 1/8 W x 25 9/16 H x 7 51/64 D in
Opening range:EF45D cavity: 32.3-34.3 W x 25.6-26.6 H in; depth 7.8 in minimum, 8.1 suggested
Electrical supply:Western 33 plug-in supply: 120 V at 60 Hz; max 12.5 A, using a 15 A circuit

See the exact model’s opening and control instructions.PuraFlame manual

LegendFlame Carl 30-Inch Electric Fireplace Insert product image

Best Budget

#2 – LegendFlame Carl 30-Inch Electric Fireplace

4.6 / 5 – 650 reviews
$326.69
Price last verified 2026-11-05 on Amazon US
+ PROS

+ Checked $326.69 price: $63.20 below Western33.
+ Four flame levels and nine mood-light choices.
+Remote heat, temperature, display, crackling and timer controls.
+ Enclosed brick-effect interior and glass front.
+Manufacturer identifies optional TR263 trim for extra coverage.
– CONS

x Smaller opening range than Western33.
x10.39-inch outer depth requires a deeper cavity than Western.
x Plug-in only; smaller checked customer-feedback pool.
KEY SPECS

Outer dimensions:30.67 x 24.25 x 10.39 in (width x height x depth)
Opening range:EF263A opening: 27.1-29.9 W x 22.7-24.1 H in; depth 9.4 in minimum, 9.7 suggested
Electrical supply:Carl 30 electrical requirement: 120 V, 60 Hz; max 12.5 A, using a 15 A circuit; plug-in
Heat settings: 750W / 1500W; supplemental heat only

See the exact model’s opening and control instructions.LegendFlame manual

Dimplex Revillusion RLG25 Electric Log Set product image

Best for Open Hearths

#3 – Dimplex RLG25 open log set

4.4 / 5 – 832 reviews
$499.00
Price last verified 2026-11-05 on Amazon US
+ PROS

+ Open logs leave existing masonry visible.
+Selected package includes glowing ash mat and remote.
+ Mirage panel and molded illuminated logs.
+ Flame-only operation without heat.
+Exact manual documents recommended opening and electrical requirements.
– CONS

x Highest checked price; no enclosed firebox included.
x Recommended 15-inch opening depth.
x Off/Low/High heat controls; no documented room thermostat.
KEY SPECS

Log-set dimensions:RLG25 body: 25.6 W x 19 H x 13 D in, per its manual
Recommended opening:Recommended viewing opening: at least 26 W x 22 H x 15 D in
Electrical supply:RLG25 plug-in requirement: 120 V at 60 Hz; 12.5 A and 1,500 W maximum, on a 15 A circuit
Heat controls:Heat off, low or high – no room-temperature thermostat in the exact manual

See the exact model’s opening and control instructions.Dimplex manual

Illustration comparing a closed PuraFlame firebox with an open Dimplex log set in masonry hearths
Original source-referenced format illustration. A closed cabinet and an open log set have different dimensions and installation requirements.

Why each pick holds its role

PuraFlame Western 33-Inch Electric: why Best Overall

Western 33 at $389.89 supplies an enclosed brick-look interior and rotary thermostat. Its shallower 8.78 in body is useful only within the manual’s opening and ventilation limits.

LegendFlame Carl 30-Inch Electric Fireplace: why Best Budget

Carl 30 at $326.69 is narrower and less expensive, with four flame levels and nine mood-light effects. Its 10.39 in depth still requires a deeper cavity than Western.

Dimplex Revillusion RLG25 Electric Log Set: why Best for Open Hearths

RLG25 at $499.00 preserves masonry visibility with open logs, ash mat and reflector. The recommended 26 x 22 x 15 in opening and absence of a room thermostat are meaningful tradeoffs.

Buyer guide: match the product to the job

Choose the visual format, then measure the narrowest width, height and depth. Check the exact manual, air path and direct outlet access. Trim cannot make an undersized cavity suitable.

+ Measure opening width, height and depth.
+ Decide between a framed cabinet and an open masonry view.
+ Confirm the outlet route, air path and prescribed clearances.
+ Price the complete installation before ordering.

Compare rated input and operating time, rather than purchase price, for energy use.Energy Vanguard heating explanation

Illustration of PuraFlame and LegendFlame remote controls on an oak table
Original source-referenced control illustration. Display details are illustrative; use the exact model instructions for operation.

Which one should you buy?

Best Overall

Choose Western 33 for a matching cabinet opening, a brick-look interior and thermostatic supplemental heat.

See it on Amazon ->

Best Budget

Choose Carl 30 for its narrower body, lower checked price and adjustable flame lighting, after checking its greater depth.

See it on Amazon ->

Best for Open Hearths

Choose RLG25 to keep an open masonry hearth visible, with sufficient depth and acceptance of manual Low/High heat settings.

See it on Amazon ->

Frequently Asked Questions

Which insert is our overall starting point?

+

Western is our conditional cabinet starting point for its finished interior, shallower body and rotary thermostat. Fit governs the recommendation.

Which pick suits a tighter budget?

+

Carl suits a matching smaller opening and the lowest checked outlay. Add any separate trim or electrical work to the budget.

When does the third pick make sense?

+

When the open masonry view matters enough to accept greater depth and no documented room thermostat.

Did ReviewGuid test these products?

+

No. This is offer and specification research. Amazon averages are customer feedback; documentary criteria are separate from physical test results.

★ FINAL PICK

PuraFlame Western 33-Inch Electric

Choose Western for a fitting cabinet, Carl for a narrower price-led option, or RLG25 for exposed masonry. Verify each opening independently before ordering.

Prices, ratings, and availability checked on 2026-11-05 and subject to change.

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *